Mary, Joseph, and Jesus
The Three Wise Men
The Magi’s Waze GPS
The Little Drummer Boy
The Little Oboe Girl
Inn Keeper
Inn Keeper’s son Tyler who does his homework in the lobby
Angel
Angel (from Rent)
Mary’s Doula, Jessica
Shepherd
Derek Shepherd (from Grey’s Anatomy)
Gender-Reveal Balloon
Donkey
Shrek
Camel
Ox
Lambs
Mariah Carey
The Metronome the Ox and Lamb use to keep time for the Drummer Boy
Passerby wondering why there are so many animals outside this inn
Joseph Understudy (in case Caleb has lacrosse)